Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is this legal?
Yes, it is legal. The wealthy have been using these strategies for years with the help of lawyers and accountants. Canada Revenue Agency has agreed with this strategy. See Canada Revenue Agency forms and publications, Interest Deductibility and Related Issues NO.: IT-533 section 31 and examples #8 and #9.

It is extremely important to work with qualified experienced professionals who fully understand the strategy and who will ensure the proper set up and recording for tax deductibility.



2. Why haven't I heard about this strategy before?
With the publication of "The Smith Manoeuvre" by Fraser Smith, a retired financial advisor, the strategy is now being brought to the public through a few financial planning firms. Bick Financial Security Corporation was an early adaptor of the concept since the book's release and is a leader in implementing the concepts.

Also, prior to 2004, the banking products to facilitate the required mortgage arrangement were not widely available. Bick Financial Security Corporation has developed relationships with several major financial institutions that enable the appropriate financial restructuring to implement the Deduct My Mortgage™ strategy.



3. What happens when interest rates change?
Because the interest costs are a deductible expense,when interest rates increase so does the deductible amount. The reverse is also true when interest rates decline, the deduction declines.



4. What if the investment performance is poor?
There is historical evidence(1) to indicate that markets can produce a conservative average annual rate of return to be 6% to 8% over a 15-25 year mortgage amortization period. Statistical data has also shown that a market can maintain a positive return 19 times out of 20 over a 5 year period(2).

The Deduct My Mortgage strategy involves the systematic exchanging of bad debt (non-deductible debt) into smart debt (deductible). This strategy can fall to a 3% annual average rate of return over the duration of the mortgage period and still be successful(3).

(1) Average performance based on 15 year rolling period (Global Equity Market): Source Concept Toolkit 73 Years of Stock Market History
(2) Assuming a managed tax rate of 42% and interest rate of 6%
(3) Average performance based on 10 year rolling period (Global Equity Market): Source: Concept Toolkit 73 Years of Stock Market History



5. What if the federal government changes the income tax rule?
Currently, interest deductibility on borrowed money for investment purposes is allowed. This can be confirmed by viewing Canada Revenue Agency forms and publications, Interest Deductibility and Related Issues NO.: IT-533 section 31 and examples #8 and #9.

If the government changes the income tax legislation, we will review the implications and identify alternative options.


6. What if I lose my job or if my marriage ends?
The strategy builds wealth over time. So, if you lose your employment income you now have an investment portfolio to draw upon until new employment is found. Be advised that interest deductibility is reduced by the amount of funds withdrawn.

If a marital break up occurs or continued unemployment persists this strategy can easily be stopped. The Deduct My Mortggae™ strategy uses common financial facilities and investments that can be stopped, withdrawn or changed with ease. In fact, the strategy is much easier to unwind, than selling your house or a business.


7. What if I worry a lot about money?
This may be the biggest concern as you may be emotionally motivated to take action based upon short-term market value fluctuations of your investment performance. We refer to this as the emotional rollercoaster. The fact is that investments are priced daily in the market, based upon what other people are willing to pay and at a price that the seller is willing to sell.

If you purchased your home last year for $200,000 and today your neighbour down the street with an identical house sold their home for $150,000 would you sell your home for $150,000?

With professional guidance we can help you rationalize emotions by focusing on the facts. As your financial advisor we are here to guide you every step of the way. Our motivation is for you to achieve financial success.


8. Where can I learn more?
1. Attend one of our regular information seminars, (see seminar registration for upcoming events).
2. Read the book "The Smith Manoeuvre", (contact us for a copy).
3. Call us for a complementary initial consultation.


This is intended for information purposes only and is not to be construed as investment advice. Borrowing to invest is suitable only for investors with higher risk tolerance. You should be fully aware of the risks and benefits associated with investment loans since losses as well as gains can be magnified. The value of your investment will vary and is not guaranteed, however you must meet your loan and income tax obligations and repay your loan in full. Consult with your financial advisor before acting on this and/or any investment.